Deeper Commentary
Exo 19:1 In the third month after the children of Israel had gone
out of the land of Egypt-
"Gone out" is s.w. "brought forth". Israel were "brought forth" from
Egypt by God; they had been unwilling to leave Egypt, preferring to serve
the Egyptians rather than Yahweh (Ex. 14:12). God had as it were forced
through His project of saving Israel by bringing them out of Egypt. And He
had done so largely for the sake of Moses, by whose faith the Red Sea
parted and they were delivered (Heb. 11:28,29). Therefore Yahweh's
bringing Israel out of Egypt was what He did for Moses, and only thereby
for His people. We too are brought out of this world towards God's Kingdom
by His grace alone, with His consistently taking the initiative in our
hearts and life circumstances, in accord with the loving intercession of
the Lord Jesus [represented by Moses]. Thus Yahweh brought Israel out of
Egypt (Ex. 18:1; 19:1; Lev. 23:43; 25:55; Num. 26:4; 33:1,3,38; Dt.
4:45,46), but Moses did (Ex. 3:10,11).
On that same day they came into the wilderness
of Sinai-
There are various options in understanding "that same day". It could
mean the same day of the month, the 15th, in which they had departed from
Egypt. Or it might mean the same day of the same month, i.e. the 3rd day
of the 3rd month. Or we could follow the Jewish view that the phrase
implies "the first day of the month". This would mean it was 45 days after
leaving Egypt, on the fifteenth day of the first month. On the next day,
Moses went up to the mountain, and then the people are given three days to
sanctify themselves. The day after that, the glory of God appeared. This
would have been fifty days after Passover, the day which was to be called
the day of Pentecost. And thus the Jewish tradition is confirmed- that the
law was given on the day of Pentecost.
Exo 19:2 When they had departed from Rephidim, and had come to the
wilderness of Sinai, they encamped in the wilderness; and there Israel
encamped before the mountain-
We are intended to connect this with how they had arrived in Rephidim
and rebelled (Ex. 17:1). They moved on from there apparently repentant,
and now encamp before Yahweh in the mountain. The impression is of a
repentant people, now suitably humble to receive God's law. At least that
is the idealized picture given. For God fell in love with Israel in the
wilderness and spread His skirt over them at Sinai, accepting them as His
wife, despite all their idolatry and weakness. And despite
their failure to sanctify themselves, and their turning away from the
intimacy of coming up to the mountain to the close fellowship with Yahweh
which Moses enjoyed.
Exo 19:3 Moses went up to God, and Yahweh called to him out of the
mountain, saying, This is what you shall tell the house of Jacob, and tell
the children of Israel-
The way they were the descendants of the historical Jacob is stressed, as
is his name change from Jacob to Israel. They were being reminded that
Jacob too had been so weak, as they were. And yet he had been accepted and
transformed by God's grace. And this was God's hope for them too.
The stress on leaving Rephidim could be to remind us of their poor behaviour there and how they must move on. This may explain the parallel between Jacob and Israel made here, to show the possibility of transformation from Jacob to Israel. "House of Jacob" is female, children of Israel is male, perhaps suggesting the covenant was for men and women. His religion was not just to be a hobby for males, as was often the case with contemporary religions.
Exo 19:4 ‘You have seen what I did to the Egyptians, and how I bore you on
eagles’ wings-
Israel's passing through the Red Sea was an undoubted type of baptism and
the new creation (1 Cor. 10:1). God brought them out of Egypt, through
the Red Sea baptism, "and brought you unto myself" (Ex. 19:4). It was as if
God was waiting for them there, in the wilderness; as He waits to receive
every man or woman who passes through the waters of baptism. Time and again
they were bidden look back to their exodus/ Red Sea experience. In times of
dire spiritual failure or sluggish indifference to their God, as well as at
their pinnacles of faith, the Spirit in the prophets directed their minds
back to these things- either by explicit statement, or by indirect allusion.
We too, as the baptized new Israel, ought to likewise look back to our
baptism with an ever-increasing appreciation.
"To Myself" could be a reference to the actual personal descent of Yahweh onto Sinai. We note that God "brought" Israel to Himself; not led them. They didn't want to come, but He so wanted them.
Exo 19:5 Now therefore-
Israel were to be a Kingdom of priests exactly because "You have seen
what I did... how I bare you on eagles' wings, and brought you unto
Myself" (Ex. 19:4-6). The redemption which we have personally experienced
must be the motivation to rise up to this challenge. The spirit of
priesthood should therefore be seen in each of us.
If you will indeed obey My voice, and keep My covenant, then you shall be My very own possession from among all peoples; for all the earth is Mine;-
"My very own possession", as a child desires to own something "of my very own", is a concept hard to appreciate in our days of private ownership and private wealth. Wealth, lands, homes etc. at that time were all collectively owned, as a family or group. Your "very own possession" was something unusual and of deep personal sentimental value; something you had personally acquired. And this was how God saw His people; they were very significant and personally valuable to Himself, and how He defined Himself as an individual. Whilst all of creation is God's in another sense, that too has [by His grace] become of collective ownership. But Israel, His people, are His very own personal possession. He likewise allows Himself, in a sense, to be defined by us.
We are to live out in practice what we have been made in status by
our gracious Father. The very fact He counts us as in Christ, as the
spotless bride of His Son, must be both felt and lived up to by us. The
way He counts us like this is a wonderful motivation to rise up to it all.
Consider how God told Israel that
if they kept His commandments,
then they would be His “peculiar treasure” (Ex. 19:5). This
conditional promise is then referred to by Moses as having been fulfilled-
Israel became His “peculiar treasure” by status even though they did
not
keep His commandments (Dt. 7:6; 14:2 s.w.; Ps. 135:4). Moses concludes by
saying that “the Lord has avouched you this day to be His peculiar people
[s.w.]… that you should keep all His commandments” (Dt. 26:18).
See what’s happening here. God said that
if they were obedient,
then they would be His special people. Yet He counted them as His
special people even though they were not obedient. And He did this so that
they would be so touched by this grace that they
would be obedient.
Exo 19:6 and you shall be to Me a kingdom of priests, and a holy nation’.
These are the words which you shall speak to the children of Israel-
God intended Israel to be "a Kingdom of priests" (Ex. 19:6). This
could be read as meaning they were to have priests for kings; but they
turned away from this by wanting a singular king who was not a priest. Or
we can understand it as meaning that the entire kingdom were to be
priests. A priest teaches and mediates for people; so we see here the
mission of Israel in this world, as a whole nation who were intended to
bring the world to Yahweh. This is what it is to be Israel, as God
intended. And these words are transferred to us in 1 Peter 2:5. “All the
people of Israel” were the builders of the spiritual house of God, i.e.
His people (Acts 4:10,11). It was God's intention that there should be no
specialist priests. It was everyone's job, to teach their neighbour and
family God's word. But His plans were ammended as their general failure
became apparent, and the Levites were chosen. But His ideal intention
remained. Thus when Israel were rejected, they were told that they as a nation could no
longer be God’s priest (Hos. 4:6). By baptism, we become spiritual Israel;
and this idea is relevant to us too. Peter picks up these words in Exodus
and applies them to every one of us, for the new covenant returns to this
original intention of the old covenant: "You also are built up a spiritual
house, an holy priesthood, to offer up spiritual sacrifices" (1 Pet.
2:5,9, quoting Ex. 19:6 LXX).
The "Kingdom of God" is not only a future political entity to be
established on earth; the term refers also to whatever God has Kingship
over now. A Kingdom is essentially a people. God's people are His Kingdom,
here and now. By entry into the body of Christ by baptism, we are like
Israel being declared as God's Kingdom on earth (Ex. 19:5,6) after their
Red Sea 'baptism'. Life in [the body of] Christ now, the Kingdom life now
[as the Lord speaks of it in Mt. 5-7], the life to be eternally
experienced in the future manifestation of the Kingdom of God on earth...
it's all about life in a community. It's not about splendid isolation now,
because it won't be about that in the eternal future either.
Exo 19:7 Moses came and called for the elders of the people, and set
before them all these words which Yahweh commanded him-
"All these words" were the invitation to be God's priestly kingdom.
The first simple step in relationship with God is to say "Yes" to that
general invitation. And then the details follow, but it seems God saw
their initial agreement as so significant. There is some parallel in the
way that the very simple gospel of the resurrected Lord Jesus is to be
taught, accepted in baptism, and then after that, those who have accepted
it are to be taught "to observe all things whatever I have commanded" (Mt.
28:20). See on :11.
Exo 19:8 All the people answered together, and said, All that Yahweh has
spoken we will do. Moses reported the words of the people to Yahweh-
"Answered together" could imply that they spoke these words in unison,
at the same time. But there was a group think here. For the
people were soon drawing back from personal meeting with God because they
refused to be personally sanctified. God of course heard those words, but Moses "reported the
words" as if this was required in order for the proposed covenant to be
formally ratified. See on :19.
Exo 19:9 Yahweh said to Moses, Behold, I come to you in a thick cloud,
that the people may hear when I speak with you, and may also believe you
forever. Moses told the words of the people to Yahweh-
The Angel told Moses that the people would hear him, "and believe you for ever".
But this was only true potentially, as are many such statements. For things turned out the opposite. At this
time, God saw no iniquity in Israel (Num. 23:21), He was the young man in
love with the girl called Israel whom He had met in the desert. And so the
record reads very positively about them. See on :21. The people
didn't believe Moses. The idea was that God's personal descent and Israel
hearing His words ought to have permanently persuaded them. But it didn't
and neither did God's descent in His Son.
Exo 19:10 Yahweh said to Moses, Go to the people, and sanctify them today
and tomorrow, and let them wash their garments-
This command to sanctify themselves suggests separation from
something. And surely the idea was that they were to repent of their
idolatry and ditch the idols of Egypt which they had taken with them
through the Red Sea (Ez. 20:8). There is no evidence they did so, for they
carried the tabernacles of other gods through the desert, along with
Yahweh's (Acts 7:43).
Exo 19:11 and be ready against the third day; for on the third day Yahweh
will come down in the sight of all the people on Mount Sinai-
"Be ready" is the phrase used in the covenant to David, rendered "be
established... be confirmed" (2 Sam. 7:16,24,26). Their readiness or
preparedness, basically their willingness, was to be the qualification for
entering the covenant. See on :7. In one sense, all we have to do is say
yes.
Exo 19:12 You shall set bounds to the people all around, saying, ‘Be
careful that you don’t go up onto the mountain, or touch its border.
Whoever touches the mountain shall be surely put to death-
Moses apparently obeyed this (:23), although there is no record of
his doing so. The Hebrew for "bounds" is literally to tie a rope; it was
but a rope. The boundary therefore made the mountain holy / sanctified
(:23). They were not to touch the holiness of Yahweh, whereas later
whatever touched holy things was made holy (s.w. Ex. 29:37; 30:29; Lev.
6:18). The implication could be that God knew that in reality, they were
not a sanctified / holy people. He had asked them to make themselves holy
by rejecting their idols, but they had not done so (:10). And so they were
warned not to touch the holy mountain, or else they would die for having
defiled God's holiness by their unholiness.
Exo 19:13 No hand shall touch him, but he shall surely be stoned or shot
through; whether it is animal or man, he shall not live’-
The commentary of Heb. 12:20 is that "They could not endure [s.w.
"uphold"] that which was commanded- If even a beast touch the mountain, it
shall be stoned". The argument in the context seems to be that Israel were
disobedient even to the peripheral command not to touch the mountain; let
alone to the actual content of the covenant. Although they disobeyed,
there is no record of their being slain. Their curiosity overcame any
respect they may have had for God's law, and thus they repeated in essence
the sin of Adam and Eve in touching and taking the forbidden fruit.
When the trumpet sounds long, they shall come up to the mountain-
LXX "when the voices and trumpets and cloud depart from off the
mountain, they shall come up on the mountain". But this didn't
happen- see on :14. They were not sufficiently sanctified; see on :10.
The cordonning off of the mountain was not therefore to stop the
people coming up it; it was to stop them coming up it prematurely. But as
it happened, they chose not to go up the mountain. They asked Moses to
deal with this amazing God, and report to them about what He wanted. They
thereby shunned intimacy with their God, in the way so many do today. They
had a passing curiosity in wanting to gaze upon their God, but when they
realized His greatness and the need for sanctification before approaching
Him- they wanted Moses to do their religion for them.
Exo 19:14 Moses went down from the mountain to the people, and sanctified
the people; and they washed their clothes-
I suggested on :10 that this command to sanctify themselves suggests
separation from something. And surely the idea was that they were to
repent of their idolatry and ditch the idols of Egypt which they had taken
with them through the Red Sea (Ez. 20:8). But Moses sanctified them in a
ritual sense. But I have argued on :10 that they were not in fact
sufficiently holy, and therefore they did not ascend the mountain as
originally planned (:13).
Exo 19:15 He said to the people, Be ready by the third day. Don’t have
sexual relations with a woman-
They had three days to sanctify themselves, and I suggested on :10
that this meant throwing away their idols and being sanctified to Yahweh
alone. But as noted on :14, they merely went through external rituals of
sanctification, and thought that washing their clothes and abstaining from
sex for three days would make them sanctified. It didn't.
Exo 19:16 It happened on the third day, when it was morning, that there
were thunders and lightnings, and a thick cloud on the mountain, and the
sound of an exceedingly loud trumpet; and all the people who were in the
camp trembled-
"Thunders" is LXX "voices"; the thunders were to be understood as the
great voice of God. And then according to Ex. 19:13 LXX "when the voices
and trumpets and cloud depart from off the mountain, they shall come up on
the mountain". But this didn't happen- see on :14. They were not
sufficiently sanctified; see on :10. Moses himself trembled (Heb. 12:21).
Exo 19:17 Moses led the people out of the camp to meet God; and they stood
at the lower part of the mountain-
The idea was as in :13 LXX "when the voices and trumpets and cloud
depart from off the mountain, they shall come up on the mountain".
But this didn't happen- see on :14. They were not sufficiently sanctified;
see on :10. Instead of all of them ascending the mountain, only Moses was
invited to ascend (:20). This was a departure from the initial intention.
And when he got to the top, he was simply told to go down and ensure the
people didn't break through the cordon and come up the mountain as
originally planned. Some of them had already touched the mountain; for the
commentary of Heb. 12:20 is that "They could not endure [s.w. "uphold"]
that which was commanded- If even a beast touch the mountain, it shall be
stoned". The argument in the context seems to be that Israel were
disobedient even to the peripheral command not to touch the mountain. The
whole narrative is the story of an intimacy with God which didn't come
about as potentially possible. And that is the sad story of so much of the
Divine-human encounter.
Exo 19:18 Mount Sinai, all of it, smoked, because Yahweh descended on it
in fire; and its smoke ascended like the smoke of a furnace, and the whole
mountain quaked greatly-
This reference to fire, smoke, furnace, earthquake and the descent of
Yahweh is very similar to the language of Divine judgment, especially of
Sodom (Gen. 19:28; Rev. 9:2). And we know from the prophets that Israel
were considered by God as Sodom. We could read this as His wrath with
Israel for breaking His simple commandments about not touching the
mountain, and for not having sufficiently sanctified themselves (see on
:10,14,18). The argument of Heb. 12 appears to be that the scene here is
one of condemnation of sinful man- and we have not been called to that,
but to salvation by grace in the new covenant in Christ. But this
condemnation wasn't the original intention; which had been rather that all
Israel would ascend Sinai and meet God (:13).
Exo 19:19 When the sound of the trumpet grew louder and louder, Moses
spoke, and God answered him by a voice-
What did Moses speak? Presumably the words of :7,8, whereby the
people had agreed to enter covenant with Yahweh. The response was that
Moses alone, and not the people as originally planned (see on :13), was
invited up to God. And was simply told to return to the people, with no
covenant, but rather a repeated message not to touch the mountain in their
unclean state (see on :10,14,15). Alternatively we can see
this as enigmatically unstated- Moses asked for 'something' and Yahweh
"answered". What Moses asked for on Sinai at other times was the salvation
of Israel. God responded by accepting them into covenant anyway.
The people were not allowed near the base of the mountain. Yet they each heard Moses speaking and God's reply, clearly by a miracle. Dt. 5:4,19 stress that Yahweh spoke directly to the people out of the fire. God's word likewise is brought personally to each person in the new covenant.
Exo 19:20 Yahweh came down on Mount Sinai, to the top of the mountain.
Yahweh called Moses to the top of the mountain, and Moses went up-
See on :19. Wherever an ordinary Israelite offered sacrifice, “I will come unto
thee [‘you’ singular] and bless thee” (Ex. 20:23 AV). This is the very
language of God coming unto Moses on the top of Sinai (Ex. 19:20 RV)- as
if to imply that the very pinnacle of Moses’ relationship with God,
meeting Him on the top of the mount, is just as attainable for each of
God’s people who truly sacrifices to Him.
God Himself is spoken of as coming, descending etc. when He ‘preaches’
to humanity (e.g. Gen. 11:5; Ex. 19:20; Num. 11:25; 2 Sam. 22:10). In Jer.
39:16, the imprisoned Jeremiah is told to "go, tell Ebed-melech..." a word
from the Lord about him. Jeremiah couldn't have literally left prison to
do so- but the idea is that a person encountering the Lord's word has as
it were experienced the Lord 'going' to him or her. And in this sense the
message of the Lord Jesus (in its essence) could 'go' to persons without
Him physically going anywhere or even existing consciously at the time (1
Pet. 3:18-21).
Exo 19:21 Yahweh said to Moses, Go down, warn the people, lest they break
through to Yahweh to gaze, and many of them perish-
We eagerly await the words of Yahweh to Moses. The narrative sets us
up to expect some profound revelation; but Moses is told simply to go all
the way back down the mountain and warn the people of their tendency to
disobedience. Heb. 12:20 says the people had touched the mountain, and
they were not sufficiently sanctified. See on :10,14,15. They had
religious curiosity, they wanted to gaze upon God- but not to personally
sanctify themselves in order to enter true relationship with Him. And that
is so true of people today.
Exo 19:22 Let the priests also, who come near to Yahweh, sanctify
themselves, lest Yahweh break forth on them-
Clearly there were some priests before Aaron and his sons were
consecrated. So many elements of the Mosaic law were in operation before
it was given, so that some of it was really just a codification of
existing concepts. But it was God's intention that all His people be
priests, and under the new covenant, this priestly language of coming /
drawing near to God is applied to all believers (Heb. 7:19). Indeed it is
through having the sure hope of the Kingdom that we are inspired to "draw
near to God" in such priestly service.
Exo 19:23 Moses said to Yahweh, The people can’t come up to Mount Sinai,
for you warned us, saying, ‘Set bounds around the mountain, and sanctify
it’-
Moses over-estimated
their obedience, so much did he love them. Unknown to him at the time,
they had touched the mountain and had broken the command not to touch it
(Heb. 12:20). And as explained on :10,13,14, they were not sufficiently
sanctified before God.
Exo 19:24 Yahweh said to him, Go down and you shall bring Aaron up with
you, but don’t let the priests and the people break through to come up to
Yahweh, lest He break forth on them-
They had religious curiosity, they wanted to gaze upon God- but not
to personally sanctify themselves in order to enter true relationship with
Him. And that is so true of people today.
If Israel broke through to gaze, Yahweh would break
through upon them (Ex. 19:24); their punishment would be appropriate to
their sin. Under the Law, every sin received an appropriate judgment, and
this anticipates the final meting out of punishment at the last day (Heb.
2:2,3). Because Israel said "No; for we will flee upon horses [and not
need Yahweh's protection]; therefore shall you flee [in the condemnation
process]: and, We will ride upon the swift; therefore shall they that
pursue you be swift" (Is. 30:16). Because Israel thought they could flee
God's judgments on swift horses, therefore their judgment came to them on
swift horses. Adam and Eve were punished in ways appropriate to their
individual failures. The lazy servant was punished out of his own mouth
(Lk. 19:22); and even in Job's time, this principle of Divine condemnation
was known (Job 9:20; 15:6). The Judaizers too were to have an "end [that]
will correspond to their deeds" (2 Cor. 11:14,15 RSV).
Exo 19:25 So Moses went down to the people, and told them-
We are left to imagine him making the long journey back to the
people, without having received the covenant as expected. He had merely
been told to ensure the people didn't break through and touch the holy
mountain. He would have realized on the climb down that they must have
sinned. Something had gone wrong, and they had not in fact been invited up
the mountain as initially planned (:13).